If I were lost at sea, given the choice to choose between 15 items, my first choice would have to be water. Water is the most important item on the list by far because you can only survive a few days without it. My next choice would have been food, so choices two and three are army rations and fishing kit. The items that I found least useful were the maps of the pacific ocean, the compass, and the boxes of chocolate.
My group had similar feelings on which items were the most important and which were the least. Kris was the most knowledgable about the subject, and was the leader of the group. Everyone else offered there input and we came up with some good ideas.